This past week, a Viriginia high school student left a complaining message on the home phone of his school's administrator, arguing that the students deserved a snow day. He left his name and number...obviously looking for a call back.
The administrator's wife returned his call instead, and it would be an understatement to say she was pissed off. She went off on him repeatedly, essentially calling him stupid and a brat.
The student turned around and posted her voicemail on youtube.com.
Since then, people have been lining up and taking sides. Here, I've taken mine.
I don't care if this kid is 17 or 18. He's still the kid. Sure, calling the home of an administrator about a clearly undeserved snow day wasn't the most brilliant game plan. And yeah, posting it on youtube wasn't real tactful or mature either. However, who is the adult here?
I don't know much about this Administrator and his wife.....but I tell you, I can guess a lot. Just by listening to her voicemail, something tells me everything is not rosy in marriageland. Wifey really hates her husband's job. Wifey is also stressed out in general and needs a spa weekend. Wifey also wishes the phone would stop ringing....you can't tell me this one call set her off like that. And if it did, well, wifey needs to take up meditation or find some valium.....
My point tho, is this woman is the adult. Her reaction is just as, if not more so, juvenille as the boy posting the voicemail for the public to hear. She should have ignored the call. And if she couldn't bring herself to just let it go, then a simple phone call to the boy requesting that he not call her home for this type of thing - that if he had a complaint, he should direct it to the school - and perhaps provide the boy with her husband's WORK number - would have been much more mature - an probably more effective - thing to do.
A school administrator has the responsibility to set an example. I would imagine his wife should too. Kids are impressionable. Even at seventeen or eighteen. They are watching for your reaction. They are testing the boundaries still - just like they do when they are three and you have to repetively tell them NO.
I see no excuse in her behavior. A reason for it? Sure! I imagine I'd be annoyed or pissed off if the kid had called my home too. But her subsequent reaction was NOT the right thing to do and she should not be patted on the back for it. She lost herself (and likely her husband) some respect. Especially in the eyes of teenagers. She's a laughing stock to them now.
How many high school kids out there have now read about this story?? How do kids like this one learn the "right" way to do things when adults don't correct them respectfully or set an example themselves?
The boy wanted an explanation of why there was no snow day. Clearly, he doesn't have much common sense since there wasn't much snow on the ground. But he deserved a decent response, not a lunatic screaming at him on the phone that he was just a punk. If we treat every kid who makes a dumb decision like they are dumb - then how will we ever teach them to make smarter decisions?
Perhaps having a child has made me into an overanalyzing cranky old lady. But I see the bigger picture all too often. Sure, it's hilarious to hear the woman go off on the tape. But frankly? It's pretty sad too.
How would the callback have gone had I been Mr. Administrator's wife?
Me: "Hello, Dave, this is Mrs. Tistdadt....I got the message you left earlier..."
Dave: "Uhhhh....."
Me: "Dave, tell me again why exactly you deserve a snow day when there is only 3 inches of snow?"
Dave: "Uhhh...like I said! It snowed, lady! We shouldn't have to go to school in this stuff!"
Me: "Dave, we got 3 inches...that comes up to your - what, ankle? Is it preventing you from walking? What about the car, Dave....is the half ton machine in your garage not capable of crushing 3 inches of fluffly white stuff that has at this point probably already been plowed from the streets?"
Dave: "Uhh....that's not the point, the point is, it SNOWED!"
Me: "Dave, lemme give you the number of my neice in Chicago. She can tell you a thing or two about snow and how snow days work. And you do realize Dave, if you had gotten a snow day today, it would have made your school year a day longer because you would have to make up for the day you missed today in June, when the weather is perfect...."
Dave: "Uhh...yeah, but..."
Me: " I'm sure you are not that much of a wimp - I mean, come on...three inches?? You can't even make a decent snowman with that. But if you really are having trouble getting to school Dave, I can come get you and bring you there. "
Dave: "Uhh, no that's ok..."
Me: "If you are still upset about this Dave, why don't you write a letter to my husand or to the school newspaper? Maybe you have a point to make, but if you really want something done about it, then that will get you results a lot faster than calling our house...."
Dave: "Uhhh...okay. Uhh...sorry..."
Me: "It's ok Dave. Go get your boots on and stay warm."
Dave: "Uhh...okay. Thanks..."

Recent Comments